Category Archives: Orwell

Ungood? It Could Work

Let’s take a trip to the past and chat about 1984 so I can catch up on my past reviews before the thought police get me, although I promise that I have officially started reading our current tome To the Lighthouse! For Andi’s 1984 review, click here.

1984 was written in 1949 and established a dark future for the citizens of that time, including the main characters Winston and Julia, who try to resist the penultimate control of the government (Big Brother). My Signet Classics version ($7 at Target- go buy it!) calls it “completely convincing” and I whole-heartedly agree!

1984

“The past, he reflected, had not merely been altered, it had actually been destroyed. For how could you establish even the most obvious fact where there existed no record outside your own memory?”

Even if someone wanted to recall something from their childhood – something simple such as the name of a European country in “Oldspeak,” the term for words prior to the Party’s control, it would be a crime to even think about it, so a citizen wouldn’t be able to talk with anyone or share that memory. “Everything melted into a mist,” and really all conversations would be forced into the present.

And what if one did remember something specifically?

“Sometimes, indeed, you could put your finger on a definite lie. It was not true, for   example, … that the Party had invented airplanes. He remembered airplanes since his earliest childhood. But you could prove nothing. There was never any evidence.”

In addition to destroying the past, the Party controls the present through the flow of information as well. Winton’s job is in the Records Department, and one of his jobs is to rewrite the present. That task is not given to one person. If the new “Oceania” won a victory over “Eurasia,” that information would be given to 3 or 4 writers, all of whom would write an article based on the information they were given. Then the Party would take parts of each and craft the information they wanted to portray. The writers wouldn’t see the finished product. Any past information to the contrary of what happened, someone’s prediction that the other side would win, for instance, would be destroyed.

“The past not only changed, but changed continuously.”

Even more frightening than this level on control is the fact that Winston was a child when the party was created and started systematically destroying history and altering the present. All it would take is one more generation for there to be absolutely no knowledge that was not Party-generated. One generation.

In addition, language itself is also being systematically destroyed and altered. Winston’s colleague’s job is to establish a new dictionary in “Newspeak.” Adjectives were almost entirely eliminated. For instance, the word “good” was kept, but “bad” was eliminated and “ungood” put in its place. All superlative adjectives such as “excellent,” “superior,” etc. were eliminated and changed to “plusgood” and “doubleplus good.”

“In the end, the whole notion of “goodness” and “badness” will be covered by only six words – in reality, only one word.”

All works of fiction – Shakespeare, Milton, Chaucer – were also being updated into “Newspeak” and the originals destroyed. By destroying and altering language, the Party destroys and alters thought – by 2050, this colleague predicted, no one would be able to consider “freedom” because that word would not exist, and therefore the concept would not exist.

This whole premise of achieving complete control by altering language and information was fascinating to me. I could write pages and pages on this, and I’m sure there are thesis papers, books, and articles already written about it. These concepts comprise the first half of the book and it was gripping.

I held on for the second half of the book as well, because the Winston and Julia plot thickens and their resistance to the government increases. Spoiler Alert – The part I remembered from high school was Winston breaking down during the torture with the rats and screaming, “Do it to Julia!” so I kept feverishly reading and turning the pages until I got to that part. I think that scene stayed with me for the last 30 years not only because of the vivid imagery and terrifying psychological torture portrayed, but because in class we focused on that section as a turning point in the novel. So kudos to all teachers, who are creating lessons that could stay with their students for a lifetime.

I won’t detail what happens after that point because you should definitely read this book! And remember, “The consequences of every act are included in the act itself. ” I had to include one more quote! However, I could also have used, “The end was contained in the beginning.” Ok, Ok, I’ll stop. The picture that goes with this post is my copy, full of sticky notes from thoughts and bits of language that stuck with me, so you can feel lucky that this post was only 893 words long!

Keep Reading!

1984, Are we there yet, Mr. Orwell?

Let’s start with 1984 the year.   The eighties what a great decade, if I do say so myself.  I was a sophomore in high school, looking forward to getting my learner’s permit and behind the wheel ofVW Bug a 1972 ½  Saturn Yellow VW Super Beetle.

Ah… the memories.  We were so cool!  Rubber bracelets, neon, bow head bands, Jordache jeans, Member’s Only jacket, acid washed jeans, leg warmers, mini skirts and BIG everything…Hair, shoes, make-up, earrings!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1980s_in_fashion

madonna

The music!  Pop and punk were the rage and MTV aired… they played music videos then!  Madonna was and still is the queen of pop. Being a teenager at the time, I can’t tell you a thing about the politics of the day or the significant events that formed the era.  So comparing the real 1984 to the novel by George Orwell is beyond me. I can tell you what I thought of the book though.

I really liked 1984, I really did.  Literally on both counts!  The book and the year!  I got my driver’s license that year!!  But let me focus on the book.  I am a nerd, I will admit it and believe I have admitted to it before.  I love sci fi and fantasy as a book genre.   1984 is a must read on the list of Nerdom – yet I had never read it!  GASP!!  I know.  I have read Isaac Asimov, Raymond Feist and JRR Tolkien… the masters.  Yet not Orwell.  Luckily, I was allowed to keep my pocket protector.

 What a great read!  I can see how the influence of this work on so many other works.  Whether it is Aldous Huxby’s Brave New World (as I mentioned before Aldous was a student of Orwell hence the influence) or The Matrix.  It is all there.
There were two things that struck me the most about this book.
The ending.  HATED IT!  I love happy endings and to have this ending was too realistic….. I want my fantasy, my dream, my happy ending!!!!  Really, Big Brother won?  Seriously?  Hell NO!  We won’t go down.  Good must triumph to evil. The masses must rise up against THE MAN and succeed.  He NEVER wins!  Where is the hope of mankind?  the perseverance?  the soul?  It is in there, 1984 had each of these characteristics in the book leading you through a fantastic story of self discovery.  I don’t want to ruin the novel for those that have not read it so I will not give too much detail.  BUT all those wonderful characteristics that make us human were squashed. I was rooting for the underdog, the human spirit that drives each of us.  We are NOT a cog in a wheel (yes, I slid in an engineering term) – a part of machine.  Yet, Big Brother succeeds in oppressing and beating the hope and spirit out of those that do not conform.  Depressing.  I do believe that we won’t see a real account of 1984 occurring in society because of the wonderful aspects that make humans different from other creatures.  So there, Orwell!
Big Bro.  What came to mind on how Big Brother influenced and observed the population’s behavior was eerily close to how marketing and targeted advertising is done today.  We are watched, our likes/dislikes, our purchases.  Advertisements then push us in a direction to buy this or that.  Think about the Like button on Facebook… even our behaviors on-line all used to learn more about the population and its behaviors and then profit from them… influence them to use a certain product… eat at the ‘right’ restaurants.  A bit close to Big Brother but not the government – it is the private sector using it to makes us purchase as they want us to.  Think about it next time receive junk mail or open any social media site.

The many books, movies and TV shows that stemmed from this one novel.  Even the term “Big Brother is watching”.  You do not need to read the book to understand the concept of this phrase.  It has permeated through our society.  Especially recently with NSA’s activities.  (I will not give an opinion on this)  The press used “Big Brother” terminology throughout its coverage.

The list of just a few that came to my mind were:

  1. The Matrix Trilogy
  1. Star Trek The New Generation
  1. Firefly
  1. Beauty and the Beast

Can any of you think of others that were influenced by 1984?